Car Buyer's Guide

BMW X3 vs Toyota Fortuner

BMW X3

BMW X3

Toyota Fortuner

Toyota Fortuner

Verdict

At RM325,800, the BMW X3 costs RM129,920 more than the RM195,880 Toyota Fortuner, but it brings 188 hp, an 8.5-second 0-100 km/h time, a 570-litre boot and a 2,865-mm wheelbase. Its 310 Nm trails the Fortuner’s 400 Nm, however, and the Toyota carries seven people rather than five. The Fortuner is the pragmatic family choice: cheaper to buy, backed by a five-year unlimited-mileage warranty and fitted with a full-size spare. The X3 is the better-equipped five-seat road SUV, with a 14.9-inch display, adaptive cruise control and 360-degree camera.

X3

Pick the BMW X3 if you want stronger 188-hp performance, a 570-litre boot and modern driver-assistance equipment in a five-seat SUV.

Fortuner

Pick the Toyota Fortuner if you need seven seats, 400 Nm of diesel torque, a full-size spare tyre and a RM129,920 lower purchase price.

Key differences

  • Price: BMW X3 RM325,800; Toyota Fortuner RM195,880.
  • Power and torque: BMW X3 188 hp and 310 Nm; Toyota Fortuner 148 hp and 400 Nm.
  • Seating and boot: BMW X3 five seats and 570 litres; Toyota Fortuner seven seats and 200 litres.
  • Transmission: BMW X3 eight-speed Steptronic; Toyota Fortuner six-speed automatic.
  • Wheelbase: BMW X3 2,865 mm; Toyota Fortuner 2,745 mm.
  • Warranty: BMW X3 two years unlimited mileage; Toyota Fortuner five years unlimited mileage.

X3

  • 188 hp, 8.5-second 0-100 km/h claim and eight-speed automatic.
  • 570-litre boot and 120-mm longer wheelbase.
  • Adaptive cruise control, autonomous braking, lane-keeping assist and 360-degree camera.
  • RM129,920 more expensive.
  • Only five seats versus the Fortuner’s seven.
  • 310 Nm is 90 Nm down on the Fortuner.

Fortuner

  • Seven seats and 400 Nm from its 2.4-litre diesel.
  • RM129,920 cheaper and covered by a five-year unlimited-mileage warranty.
  • Full-size 17-inch alloy spare and 80-litre fuel tank.
  • 148 hp is 40 hp below the X3.
  • 200-litre boot is 370 litres smaller than the X3’s.
  • No blind-spot system, autonomous braking, lane-keeping assist, adaptive cruise control or reverse camera.
Price & overview
PriceRM325,800RM195,880✓
Body typeSUVSUV
SegmentCompact ExecutiveTruck/4X4
AssemblyCKDCKD
Ownership
Road tax / yearRM439✓RM754
Powertrain
Engine Tech16-valve DOHC direct injection with twin-scroll turbocharger, variable valve timing and mild hybrid assistance16-valve DOHC with Common-rail Direct Injection, Variable Geometry Turbocharger and Variable Valve Timing
Capacity1,998 cc2,393 cc
Horsepower188 hp at 4,400 rpm✓148 hp at 3,400 rpm
Torque310 Nm at 1,500 rpm400 Nm at 1,600 rpm✓
Cylinder ArrangementInline 4Inline 4
FuelPetrol Hybrid/REVDiesel
Bore × Stroke—92 mm × 90 mm
Compression Ratio—15.6
Drivetrain
TransmissionConventional AutomaticConventional Automatic
Transmission Name8-speed Steptronic6-speed Automatic with Sequential Shifter
Gears86
Transmission ManufacturerZFToyota
DrivelineAll Wheel DriveAll Wheel Drive
Performance & Efficiency
0-100 km/h8.5 seconds—
Top Speed215 km/h—
Dimensions
Length4,755 mm4,795 mm
Width1,920 mm1,855 mm
Height1,660 mm1,835 mm
Wheelbase2,865 mm2,745 mm
Weight—2,090 kg
Fuel Tank—80 litres
Doors55
Seats57
Boot Space570 litres✓200 litres
Front Tyre245/50R19265/65R17
Rear Tyre245/50R19265/65R17
Spare TyreN/A, Tyre Repair KitFull-size 17" Alloy
Factory TyresContinental EcoContact 6 QBridgestone Dueler A/T
Chassis
AssemblyMalaysia (CKD)Malaysia (CKD)
Front SuspensionMacPherson StrutDouble Wishbones
Rear SuspensionMulti-linkMulti-Link
Front Wheels19" Y-spoke M Alloys17" Alloy
Rear Wheels19" Y-spoke M Alloys17" Alloy
SteeringRack & Pinion (Electric Power Steering)Rack and Pinion (Hydraulic Power Steering)
Crash Safety Ratings
ANCAP—5 stars — With 7 airbags and stability control
ASEAN NCAP—4 stars — With 3 airbags and no stability control
Safety
Airbags6 (Driver and Front Passenger, Front Side, Curtain Airbags)7 (Driver and Passenger, Driver Knee, Front Side, Front and Rear Curtain)
ABS/EBD✓✓
Stability Control✓✓
Alarm✓✓
Immobilizer✓✓
Airbag Disable Function✓✓
Child Safety LockManual for Rear DoorsManual for Rear Doors
Seat Belts5 Three-point7 Three-point
Blind Spot Info System✓—
ISOFIXAvailable for 2 Outer Rear SeatsAvailable on 2 Outer Middle Row Seats
Autonomous Braking SystemYes—
Lane-keeping AssistSteering CorrectionNo
Collision Warning✓—
Seatbelt ReminderAll SeatsFront Seats Only
Lighting
HeadlampsLED ProjectorHalogen Projector
TaillampsFull LEDLED Combination
LED Daytime Running Lights✓—
Front Foglamps—✓
Rear Foglamps✓✓
Wing Mirror Turn Indicators✓✓
Cabin
Front SeatsPowered Front SeatsManual Adjustable
Rear Seats40:20:40 Split-folding60:40 Split-folding Middle Row with one-touch tumble, 50:50 Split-folding Last Row with one-touch space up
Front Air-conDual-zone Automatic Climate ControlManual Air-con
Rear Air-conSingle-zone Automatic Climate ControlRear Vents with Blower control
Power Sockets1 Front, 1 Wireless Charger, 2 USB-C Front, 2 USB-C Rear1 Front, 1 Middle Row, 1 Boot, 1 Front USB
Interior LightingMap Lights & Ambient LightingMap Lights and Ambient Lights
Cup Holders2 Front, 2 Rear4 Front, 2 Middle Row, 2 Last Row
Audio14.9" BMW Curved Display Live Cockpit Professional, 6 SpeakerRadio CD/MP3 Player with 6 Speakers
Convenience
Power WindowsFour Windows, Auto Up and Down with Anti-pinchFour Windows, Auto Up and Down with Anti Pinch
Engine StartKeyless Push ButtonKeyless Push Button
LocksKeyless OperationKeyless Operation
Auto Start/Stop✓—
Auto Headlamps✓✓
Auto Wipers✓—
Cruise ControlAdaptive Cruise Control—
Tiptronic—✓
Paddle Shift✓—
Steering Audio Control✓✓
Steering Tilt✓✓
Steering Telescopic✓✓
Boot OperationPowered Boot with Contactless OpeningManual Operation
Parking Sensor Front6 Sensors2 Sensors
Parking Sensor Rear6 Sensors2 Sensors
Reverse CameraYes, 360-degree View Monitor—
Auto ParkingYes—
Folding Wing Mirrors✓✓
Bluetooth✓✓
Navigation✓—
Head-up Display✓—
Hill Start Assist✓✓
Instrument ClusterFull LCD MonitorBacklit Analogue
Parking BrakeElectronicHandbrake
Convenience Notes—Qi Wireless Charger, Premium Solar and Security Tint, Front Digital Video Recorder
Warranty
Warranty Mileage ManufacturerUnlimitedUnlimited
Warranty Mileage ExtendedUnlimited—
Warranty Manufacturer2 years5 years✓
Warranty Extended3 years—

Specs shown for the selected variant of each car. ✓ marks the better figure where lower/higher is objectively better. Road tax: West Malaysia, private registration.

X3 vs Fortuner FAQ

Is the BMW X3 or Toyota Fortuner better?

The BMW X3 is better for five-seat road use, performance and safety technology, with 188 hp, a 570-litre boot and adaptive cruise control. The Toyota Fortuner is better for seven occupants, 400 Nm of diesel torque and a far lower RM195,880 entry price.

What is the price difference?

The BMW X3 costs RM325,800 and the Toyota Fortuner costs RM195,880, putting the BMW RM129,920 higher.

Which has more luggage space, the BMW X3 or Toyota Fortuner?

The BMW X3 has the larger quoted boot at 570 litres, compared with 200 litres for the Toyota Fortuner. The Fortuner counters with a third row and seven seats; the X3 has five seats.

More comparisons

Buying one of these? Sell your old car, get paid in 24 hours

Related PaulTan.org Content: Motorsports | Electric: Electric | Malaysia: Malaysia | Featured: Featured | Tech | Reviews: Reviews