Car Buyer's Guide

MINI Countryman S Electric vs S All4

MINI Countryman S Electric

MINI Countryman S Electric

MINI Countryman S All4

MINI Countryman S All4

Verdict

For just RM2,000 more, the Countryman S All4 trades the Electric’s 313 hp, 494 Nm punch and 5.6-second 0-100 km/h time for a 201 hp, 300 Nm petrol drivetrain that reaches 228 km/h. That is not a persuasive upgrade for most Malaysian buyers. The Electric also cuts annual road tax from RM439 to RM335, travels up to 432 km on its 66.5-kWh battery and supports 22 kW AC or 130 kW DC charging. Pick the All4 only if petrol refuelling and its higher top speed matter more than faster acceleration and EV ownership.

S Electric

Pick the MINI Countryman S Electric if you can charge regularly and want 313 hp, 494 Nm, a 432-km claimed range and lower RM335 annual road tax.

S All4

Pick the MINI Countryman S All4 if you need petrol refuelling flexibility, an 8-speed automatic and its 228-km/h top speed.

Key differences

  • Price: MINI Countryman S Electric RM258,888; MINI Countryman S All4 RM260,888.
  • Power and torque: Electric has two motors producing 313 hp and 494 Nm; All4 has a 1,998-cc turbo four-cylinder producing 201 hp and 300 Nm.
  • 0-100 km/h: Electric 5.6 seconds; All4 7.4 seconds.
  • Top speed: Electric 180 km/h; All4 228 km/h.
  • Running energy: Electric has a 66.5-kWh battery, 432-km EV range, 22-kW AC and 130-kW DC charging; All4 has a 54-litre petrol tank.
  • Annual road tax: Electric RM335; All4 RM439.

S Electric

  • 313 hp and 494 Nm from two motors.
  • Quicker 5.6-second 0-100 km/h time.
  • 432-km claimed range, 130-kW DC charging and RM104 lower annual road tax.
  • 180-km/h top speed is 48 km/h lower than the All4.
  • No full LCD instrument cluster is listed, while the All4 gets one.

S All4

  • 228-km/h top speed.
  • 1,998-cc turbo petrol motor with an 8-speed Steptronic Sports automatic.
  • Full LCD instrument cluster.
  • RM2,000 higher purchase price.
  • 112 hp and 194 Nm down on the Electric, with a 1.8-second slower 0-100 km/h time.
  • RM439 annual road tax is RM104 more than the Electric's.
Price & overview
PriceRM258,888✓RM260,888
Body typeSUVSUV
SegmentC-SegmentC-Segment
AssemblyCBUCBU
Ownership
Road tax / yearRM335✓RM439
Powertrain
Engine Tech400V architecture16-valve DOHC with direct fuel injection, turbocharger, variable valve timing
Capacity—1,998 cc
Horsepower—201 hp at 5,000 rpm
Torque—300 Nm at 1,500 rpm
Cylinder Arrangement—Inline 4
FuelElectricPetrol
Bore × Stroke—82 mm × 94.6 mm
Number of Motors2—
Motor Horsepower313 hp—
Motor Torque494 Nm—
Battery Capacity66.5 kWh—
EV Range432 km—
Charging Rate (AC)22 kW—
Charging Rate (DC)130 kW—
Drivetrain
TransmissionSingle Ratio AutomaticConventional Automatic
Transmission Name—8-Speed Steptronic Sports Automatic
Gears—8
DrivelineAll Wheel DriveAll Wheel Drive
Performance & Efficiency
0-100 km/h5.6 seconds✓7.4 seconds
Top Speed180 km/h228 km/h✓
Dimensions
Length4,433 mm4,433 mm
Width1,843 mm1,843 mm
Height1,656 mm1,656 mm
Wheelbase2,692 mm2,692 mm
Fuel Tank—54 litres
Doors55
Seats55
Boot Space460 litres460 litres
Front Tyre245/40R20245/40R20
Rear Tyre245/40R20245/40R20
Factory TyresPirelli P ZeroPirelli P Zero, Michelin e-Primacy
Chassis
AssemblyGermany (CBU)Germany (CBU)
Front SuspensionMacPherson StrutMacPherson Strut
Rear SuspensionMulti-linkMulti-link
Front Wheels20" Alloys20" Alloys
Rear Wheels20" Alloys20" Alloys
SteeringRack and Pinion (Electric Power Assist)Rack and Pinion (Electric Power Assist)
Safety
Airbags6 (Driver and Passenger, Front Side, Curtain)6 (Driver and Passenger, Front Side, Curtain)
ABS/EBD✓✓
Stability Control✓✓
Alarm✓✓
Immobilizer✓✓
Airbag Disable Function✓✓
Child Safety LockManual for Rear DoorsManual for Rear Doors
Seat Belts5 Three-point belts5 Three-point belts
Blind Spot Info System✓✓
ISOFIXAvailable on 2 Outer Rear Seats, Front Passenger SeatAvailable on 2 Outer Rear Seats, Front Passenger Seat
Autonomous Braking SystemYesYes
Lane-keeping AssistSteering CorrectionSteering Correction
Collision Warning✓✓
Seatbelt ReminderAll SeatsAll Seats
Lighting
HeadlampsAdaptive LED Projector with High Beam AssistAdaptive LED Projector with High Beam Assist
TaillampsFull LEDFull LED
LED Daytime Running Lights✓✓
Rear Foglamps✓✓
Wing Mirror Turn Indicators✓✓
Cabin
Front SeatsPowered Front Seats with Driver's Side Memory and Massage FunctionPowered Front Seats with Driver's Side Memory and Massage Function
Rear Seats40:20:40 Split-folding, Manual Recline40:20:40 Split-folding, Manual Recline
Front Air-conDual-zone Automatic ClimateDual-zone Automatic Climate
Rear Air-conRear VentsRear Vents
Power Sockets1 Front, 2 USB C, 1 Wireless Charger, 2 USB C Rear1 Front, 2 USB C, 1 Wireless Charger, 2 USB C Rear
Interior LightingMap Lights and Ambient LightsMap Lights and Ambient Lights
Cup Holders2 Front, 2 Rear2 Front, 2 Rear
Audio9.4" OLED Display with MINI OS, Apple CarPlay and Android Auto, Harman Kardon Sound System9.4" OLED Display with MINI OS, Apple CarPlay and Android Auto, Harman Kardon Sound System
Convenience
Power WindowsFour Windows, Auto Up and Down with Anti-PinchFour Windows, Auto Up and Down with Anti-Pinch
Engine StartKeyless Flip SwitchKeyless Flip Switch
LocksKeyless OperationKeyless Operation
Auto Start/Stop✓✓
Auto Headlamps✓✓
Auto Wipers✓✓
Cruise ControlActive Cruise ControlActive Cruise Control
Paddle Shift✓✓
Steering Audio Control✓✓
Steering Tilt✓✓
Steering Telescopic✓✓
Boot OperationPowered Tailgate, with Contactless OpeningPowered Tailgate, with Contactless Opening
Parking Sensor Front6 Sensors6 Sensors
Parking Sensor Rear6 Sensors6 Sensors
Reverse CameraYes, with 360-degree View MonitorYes, with 360-degree View Monitor
Auto ParkingYesYes
Folding Wing Mirrors✓✓
Bluetooth✓✓
Navigation✓✓
Head-up Display✓✓
Hill Start Assist✓✓
Instrument Cluster—Full LCD Monitor
Parking BrakeElectronicElectronic
Warranty
Warranty Mileage ManufacturerUnlimitedUnlimited
Warranty Mileage ExtendedUnlimitedUnlimited
Warranty Manufacturer2 years2 years
Warranty Extended2 years2 years
Warranty NotesRepair Inclusive extendable up to 5 years, 8-year/160,000 km Battery WarrantyRepair Inclusive extendable up to 5 years

Specs shown for the selected variant of each car. ✓ marks the better figure where lower/higher is objectively better. Road tax: West Malaysia, private registration.

S Electric vs S All4 FAQ

Is the MINI Countryman S Electric or MINI Countryman S All4 better?

The MINI Countryman S Electric is the better buy on these figures: it is RM2,000 cheaper, has 313 hp and 494 Nm, reaches 100 km/h in 5.6 seconds and has lower annual road tax. The All4 suits buyers who require petrol refuelling and a 228-km/h top speed.

What is the price difference?

The MINI Countryman S Electric costs RM258,888, while the MINI Countryman S All4 costs RM260,888. The All4 is RM2,000 more expensive.

How do charging and refuelling differ between them?

The Electric uses a 66.5-kWh battery with a 432-km claimed range, 22-kW AC charging and 130-kW DC charging. The All4 uses petrol and has a 54-litre fuel tank.

More comparisons

Buying one of these? Sell your old car, get paid in 24 hours

Related PaulTan.org Content: Featured: Featured | Reviews: Reviews | Electric: Electric | News: News | Tech | Malaysia: Malaysia